hello Toner ,
i had a similar problem several years ago when xerox first came out with their medical coverage costing us more . for years i had been covered by UnitedHealthcare under some ' less than high deductable ' plan that didn't cost me very much and , of course , i was dumb ( as to the costs of health care ) and happy in my ignorance and rarely used my health care provider coverage anyway .
AFTER xerox had to increase our costs because their costs were climbing through the ceiling , if i had stayed with the same carrier , my health care expense was going to increase by a factor of 4 , or 400% . that's when i took a serious look at ALL my options and began to choose a cheaper ' high ' deductable plan . in my different plan options , the difference in deductables this year isn't that much . my deductable with my ' high ' deductable Aetna is $1,500 ( single ) and $3,000 ( family ) . in a ' moderate ' deductable plan offered to me , the deductable is $1,200 ( single ) and $2,400 ( family ) . and in a ' low ' deductable plan offered to me the deductable is $600 ( single ) and $1,200 ( family ) . and finally in the ' blended ' option the deductable is $600 ( single ) and $1,200 ( family ) . after that deductable is paid , the coverage is pretty much exactly the same .
as you can see , to my way of thinking anyway

, there isn't $900 worth of difference between the single deductable on all three options and $1,800 worth of difference between the options on the family deductable ; and yet , the difference in the costs or premiums is lot higher with the lower deductable plans and alot cheaper with the ' high ' deductable plan . so , i'd rather save thousands a year in my annual costs and pay the difference IF i need health care in my deductable .
i'm just glad i have a choice to choose a cheaper plan and still maintain some kind of ' catastrophic ' coverage that would threaten my critical mass and deplete / hurt my retirement funds if i had to pay for the whole bill without some kind of medical coverage .
and , by the way , i'm still waiting for my enrollment package from Aetna for their Health Saving Account and still intend to make a pro - rated deposit for this calendar year and a full deposit next calendar year . i'll let ya , and this topic , know when i get it . my intent is to get a FULL tax deduction for money deposited in this account and use that money for paying my ( higher ? ) deductables and have it earn me tax free income while it's sitting there waiting for me to write checks against or ' swip ' my debt card . sounds like a ' win , win ' situation to me . B) .